Why Columbus Sellers Choose Xenia Coin Shop
Know More, Get More
Our offers are based on live auction data from Heritage, Stacks, and eBay—not generic price guides or quick melt-value calculations. You'll get what your coins are actually worth in today's market.
Transparent, Honest Evaluations
We show you exactly how we determine value—metal content, rarity, grading, and collector demand. You'll understand every number.
Immediate Payment
When it comes to selling precious assets, you shouldn't have to wait for a payout. When you accept an offer from us, you'll walk out with cash or a check on the very same day.
40+ Years of Expertise, ANA Member
As a proud ANA member and an NGC- and PCGS-authorized precious metals dealer, we serve the community in the best way we can—with honesty and integrity.
What We Buy in Columbus
Gold and silver coins, 90% silver coins (pre-1965 dimes, quarters, half dollars), Morgan and Peace silver dollars, certified coins (graded and slabbed), raw coins, and complete collections, key-date rarities, inherited and estate collections.
Inherited a Collection in Columbus?
Many Columbus-area families come to us after inheriting a parent's or grandparent's collection. We'll sit down with you, go through everything, and explain what's valuable and why.
No jargon, no pressure—just clear guidance.
Convenient Location Near Columbus
We're located in Xenia, an easy drive from Columbus via I-70 and US-35. Many Columbus clients visit us for our market knowledge and fair pricing.
Address: 30 W 2nd St, Xenia, OH 45385 Phone: (937) 376-2807
